Liberal and Republican perspectives in the sentences of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights and the jurisdictional bodies of Chile: the case of "The Last Temptation of Christ"

Liberalismo y Republicanismo en las sentencias de la Corte Interamericana de Derechos Humanos y los órganos jurisdiccionales de Chile: el caso de “La última tentación de Cristo”

##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.sidebar##


Ver / Descargar
PDF (Español (España)) FLIP HTML (Español (España))

How to Cite
Cisneros Yescas, G. I. (2018). Liberal and Republican perspectives in the sentences of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights and the jurisdictional bodies of Chile: the case of "The Last Temptation of Christ". Revista Jurídica Piélagus, 17(1), 27–36. https://doi.org/10.25054/16576799.1559
More Citation Formats
Published: Jun 25, 2018
Doi
https://doi.org/10.25054/16576799.1559
Dimensions
PlumX
Issue
Vol. 17 No. 1 (2018)
Section
Research
License terms / See

The author (or authors) of the article titled: ________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________, which is submitted to the editorial process, certifies and authorizes the following considerations:

 

  • I certify that I am a primary author of the article presented for possible publication. I guarantee that the entire content is a product of my intellectual contribution. All information and references to any material already published are correctly attributed and included in the references and citations. In cases when it is required, I have obtained the necessary permissions from those who possess the property rights.
  • The article has not been published nor submitted simultaneously to any other serial publication for editorial consideration.
  • I certify that all the references and cites in the article are cited according to the journal’s guidelines.
  • I authorize the journal to evaluate and ask for external evaluation (peer reviewers).
  • I guarantee that all the materials presented are entirely free of copyright. I am responsible for any lawsuit or any complaint related to intellectual property rights. I release Surcolombiana University of any charge.
  • I authorize the journal to send emails to solve any situation presented during the editorial process.
  • In the case that the article is approved for publication, as author and owner of the copyright, I transfer the rights to the journal unlimited time to include the manuscript in the Piélagus Journal. The text can be reproduced, edited, exhibited, and circulated in the country and abroad. That process can be through print, electronic publication, CD ROM, internet, full text or any other means known or to be known.

 

By completing the following, I confirm the previous to be true and agree to the aforementioned terms on __________ (month) the ____ (day), 20__ in ___city____, (____Country__).

Statement of originality

##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.main##

Gerardo Isaac Cisneros Yescas
Universidad de Vanderbilt
Abstract
This article analyzes and compares the judgment of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights (IACHR) and that of the Court of Appeals of Santiago (TAS by its Spanish acronym) in relation to the film The Last Temptation of Christ by Martin Scorsese (1988). The main hypothesis is that IACHR in its mandate made a liberal-constitutional interpretation of the issue, while the Court of Appeals of Santiago and the Supreme Court of Justice of Chile addressed the issue according to political republicanist perspective. This case allows us to clearly appreciate how different theoretical conceptions materialize concretely and generate different consequences in the decisions of jurisdictional bodies regarding political and social problems.
Keywords

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.details##

Author Biography / See

Gerardo Isaac Cisneros Yescas, Universidad de Vanderbilt

Dr. en Investigación en  Ciencias Sociales con mención en Ciencia Política. El autor fue asesor en el Instituto Electoral de la Ciudad de México. Ha publicado en Revistas como Política y Gobierno, Colombia Internacional y la Revista Mexicana de Ciencias Políticas y Sociales, entre otras. Actualmente es Investigador Postdoctoral en el Departamento de Ciencia Política de la Universidad de Vaderbilt.

References

Bibliografía

I. Aguilar, Antonio (2000), “El sonido y la furia: crítica de la persuasión multicultural” en Isonomía, XII, pp. 53-73.

II. Berlin, Isaiah (1974), “Dos conceptos de libertad” en Isaiah Berlin, Libertad y necesidad en la historia, Revista de occidente, Madrid, pp. 132-184.

III. Bobbio, Norberto (2005), Teoría general de la política, Trotta, Madrid.

IV. Bobbio, Norberto; Bovero, Michelangelo (1994), Sociedad y estado en la filosofía moderna. Modelo iusnaturalista y el modelo hegeliano-marxiano, FCE, México.

V. Bovero, Michelangelo (2011), “Prefacio. Nuevas reflexiones sobre democracia y constitución” en Pedro Salazar, La democracia constitucional Una radiografía teórica, México, FCE.

VI. Corte Interamericana de Derechos Humanos (CIDH) (2001), Caso "La última tentación de Cristo" (Olmedo Bustos y otros) vs. Chile, Sentencia 5 de febrero de 2001.

VII. Gargarella, Roberto (1999), "El embate comunitarista" en Roberto Gargarella, Las teorías de la justicia después de Rawls. Un breve manual de filosofía política, Paidós, Barcelona.

VIII. ____________ (1999b), “El republicanismo” en Roberto Gargarella, Las teorías de la justicia después de Rawls. Un breve manual de filosofía política, Paidós, Barcelona.

IX. ____________ (2002), "La comunidad igualitaria y sus enemigos. Liberalismo, republicanismo e igualitarismo", en Andrés Hernández (Comp.), Republicanismo contemporáneo. Igualdad, democracia deliberativa y ciudadanía, Siglo del hombre editores, Universidad de los Andes, Bogotá.

X. Kant, Immanuel (2004), Principios Metafísicos de Derecho, España, Espuela de plata.

XI. Ovejero, Felix, et. al., (2004), "Introducción", en Ovejero et. al. (Comps), Nuevas ideas republicanas. Autogobierno y libertad, Paidós, Barcelona.

XII. Pettit, Philip (2004), "Liberalismo y republicanismo", en Ovejero et. al. (Comps), Nuevas ideas republicanas. Autogobierno y libertad, Paidós, Barcelona.

XIII. Rawls, John (2012), Teoría de la justicia, FCE, México.

XIV. Rousseau, Jean-Jacques (2004), El contrato social, España, Istmo.

XV. Sandel, Michael (1997), “The constitution of the procedural republic: liberal rights and civic virtues”, en Fordham law review, Volumen 66.

XVI. Sabine, George (2004), “El redescubrimiento de la comunidad: Rousseau” en George Sabine, Historia de la teoría política, México, FCE.

XVII. Salazar, Pedro (2011), La democracia constitucional. Una radiografía teórica, FCE, México.

XVIII. Tribunal de Apelaciones de Santiago (1997), García Valdés, Sergio y otros con Consejo de Calificación Cinematográfica. [Recurso de protección. - 17-6-1997], documento electrónico [http://www.docstoc.com/docs/122941623/TOMO-XCIV---A%EF%BF%BDo-1997].

OJS System - Metabiblioteca |